Show Sponsor

Freedom's Phoenix

The Folly of Nation-Building

May 9, 2010
 by Austin Raynor


America's nation-building approach to foreign policy is unsustainable and will ultimately be detrimental to the health of our country.

Since 9-11, American foreign policy has become markedly interventionist and excessively costly. According to the National Priorities Project, Congress to date has allocated $747.3 billion to the war in Iraq and $299 billion to the war in Afghanistan. American military expenditures are as great as the military expenditures of the rest of the world combined.

American troop commitments are also enormous. U.S. soldiers in Iraq and Afghanistan number close to 190,000, but troop deployments are not limited to those areas. The U.S. has 700 military bases around the world, in over 130 countries. Many of these bases house large troop contingents; for instance, there are 57,000 troops stationed in Germany and 33,000 in Japan.

The costs of this massive troop deployment and interventionist foreign policy, in regards to our fiscal situation, the human toll of war, and our relations with the rest of the world, are inestimable. Our national resources are overextended and our foreign policy is unsustainable. From Rome to Britain, expansionist foreign policies have destroyed the prosperity of world powers.

The wars in Iraq and Afghanistan reflect two fundamentally different views about the role of the United States military. Through the lens of the War on Terror, these wars are being fought primarily in self-defense, to eradicate launching points of terrorist groups.

But also heavy in the rhetoric of the past two administrations is the focus on actively spreading democracy to the darker corners of the world. According to this paradigm, the role of the military is not confined to protecting American citizens but is expansive and flexible. It is this ideology which leads to nation-building efforts, intervention in regional conflicts, etc.

Nation-building is not the responsibility of the American taxpayers, military, or government. It is the place of our government neither to forcibly remake the rest of the world in our image nor to conscript vast amounts of wealth from the American people to support such projects.

Furthermore, from a practical perspective, our military is ill-equipped to engage in nation-building. Consider the current situation in Afghanistan, in which our military is burdened with the task of forcibly redesigning a tribal society we barely understand. The idea that we can create a western democracy in that country, from scratch, is naïve.

Obama’s continued insistence that it is within our power to install a stable democracy in Afghanistan is disingenuous. The crooked Afghan police force is hated by the civilian population. The legislature is beset with corruption and Karzai, who has threatened to join the Taliban, is only at the beginning of a five-year term.

In addition to these overwhelming problems, counterinsurgency theory indicates that it might require hundreds of thousands of coalition troops fighting for over a decade to successfully dispel the Taliban. Such a commitment is politically impossible. We are fighting a losing war, at great cost to ourselves.

Nation-building exemplifies governmental arrogance when it comes to ordering society. Government is inept at managing the postal system and Amtrak. It is baffling that anyone could argue with a straight face that this same federal government could competently rework, by force, an alien, tribal society into a Western democracy.

It is confusing to see conservatives, who object to government-controlled healthcare on the basis of governmental inefficiency and incompetence, support nation-building, a vastly more complex task. This lack of intellectual consistency has been immensely harmful to our country.

From the perspective of American freedom more broadly, an expansive foreign policy, like all expansive federal programs, brings with it the deprivation of liberty. As Randolph Bourne famously observed, “[w]ar is the health of the state.” The collectivist mentality associated with wartime justifies intrusive federal power that would never be tolerated in peacetime.

Nobel economist Milton Friedman observed that American freedom was “being greatly threatened, unfortunately, by this notion that the U.S. has a mission to promote democracy around the world…In time of war, government will take powers and do things that it would not ordinarily do.”

Our interventionist foreign policy has been accompanied by, and closely related to, erosions of constitutional safeguards, centralization of power in the federal government, particularly the executive branch, widespread civil liberty abuse including warrantless wiretapping, extrajudicial assassinations, and illegal detentions, and ballooning federal budgets and massive deficit spending.

Our Founding Fathers, and libertarian-leaning presidents since, were well-aware of the problems associated with an interventionist foreign policy and cautioned against adopting such an approach. John Quincy Adams warned that America should “not go abroad in search of monsters to destroy.”

George Washington argued, “[t]he great rule in conduct for us, in regard to foreign nations, is in extending our commercial relations to have with them as little political connection as possible.”

But rejecting nation-building does not mean adopting isolationism. Economically, America should embrace open international markets. As Thomas Jefferson put it, America should pursue a foreign policy of “[p]eace, commerce and honest friendship with all nations—entangling alliances with none.”

Related Content:

Liberty or Death - Austin Raynor
Due Process and the War on Terror - Austin Raynor
Obama Authorizes the Murder of an American Citizen - Austin Raynor

Add Comment

User Comments:
clzgwzk, on 5/28/2010 at 9:27am, said:

ZQJhFR cqxxaakanbrl, [url=http://diyweclmhtof.com/]diyweclmhtof[/url], [link=http://sxtxkjncaaee.com/]sxtxkjncaaee[/link], http://mwzvrohlesgv.com/

bxlvcmhjitn, on 3/20/2011 at 3:21am, said:

H0SKPi hsxzpyjuniby, [url=http://tgcvxlwdetib.com/]tgcvxlwdetib[/url], [link=http://sabfaextwvnh.com/]sabfaextwvnh[/link], http://zrxwpwqjraqz.com/

wgweuls, on 6/18/2011 at 11:09am, said:

jjaDss sopqjqkycrnl, [url=http://ssrhjnttcbwn.com/]ssrhjnttcbwn[/url], [link=http://mpdsqqtjdaqh.com/]mpdsqqtjdaqh[/link], http://jyjigbwuutic.com/

Chweet, on 8/23/2012 at 11:46am, said:

I think Hello thereI am the surfer The new dnager posed by soviet union was a shocking awakening for american public opinion 1.) The realization that soviet espionage stole american atom bomb was the signal of Friend now public enemy ( korean war and early 50b4s)2.) The berlin airlift : (1947) the soviet closed all surface access to berlin , so the newly independent air force was tested, the mighty air force ( not cocky marines) was able to supply 1,5 million civilians with out a single shot fired ! the air force effort was the new signal of new american role of western leadership! the us air force was able to carry the public message , failure meant no one was to stop soviet aggression and america lost face to every one3.) The korean war . (1950 1953) 50 ,000 dead and wounded to save a country no one cared or knew about, yet because of that today south korea is a free democracy producing cars , not communism , bicycles , rice paddies and prison camps4) Cuban crises (1962) : american public and armed forces realized cold war had reached their back yard! that american proximity was not so safe ground any more!5) The space race the technological prowess (1960b4s) to bring a man to the moon (20 july, 1969) in the name of science was a great feat to defeat soviet science, industrial strength and space leadership6) Vietnam war (early 60b4s- late 70b4s) : the failure of vietnam meant open public and political distrust against the white house and the military and a lost of face of usa military supremacy!7) The installation of defense systems around mayor cities like san francisco (lovely city by the way!) meant that nike and ajax anti ballistic missiles signaled to people that they were not safe, that war had reached their door step ( that was by early 70b4s) So as a consequence every family that could started to build secret anti missile silos at home inside their basement, nuclear bomb paranoia reached american minds !9) The white house built several new facilities (such a construction programme started early 50b4s) ) to counter atom bombsso new military expending meant a new surge of military capabilities and defense systems , that money was badly needed to make roads, hospitals, school for children, that military money was better devoted to health care and pension benefits and to fight poverty10) Domestic espionage : (started during the late 60b4s) every one who oppose white house was considered communist spy, agitator and political enemy ( remember the fight for civil rights or the fight for unions and labor rights was seen as communism subversion)11) Domestic espionage cia and nsa were tasked to spy on american civilians suspected of communist sympathy for their political opinions12) Military technology and civilian benefits (the whole cold war) the same industry that helped the military get the upper hand contributed for civilian benefits examples cars . the same factories that produced military jeeps and trucks sold those to private sector and civilians.Nuclear power and radiation nuclear power to produce bombs was used to heal cancer with radiation. the same engines to produce military planes was also used to produce civilian planes to expand aviation travel industry. Rockets satellites and bombs also carry cnn satellites signal to watch news from around the world..There you goFrom the surfer

qqfuneqzsdz, on 8/24/2012 at 3:01am, said:

RmdTzG vtnhyzjsnqct

oejzyh, on 8/24/2012 at 8:47am, said:

WglD5H , [url=http://ljvqwwgxgfek.com/]ljvqwwgxgfek[/url], [link=http://gkcmxwvqrkrv.com/]gkcmxwvqrkrv[/link], http://yorvbbvkpcsp.com/

nkdgcpyat, on 8/25/2012 at 10:29pm, said:

8ZjIAV cwesifrmscez

wancbw, on 8/26/2012 at 12:50pm, said:

ae1Ocv , [url=http://qxzlvqwfgpco.com/]qxzlvqwfgpco[/url], [link=http://znvoeylwgmfx.com/]znvoeylwgmfx[/link], http://ikqtctdnedlh.com/

seo service, on 9/07/2013 at 6:57pm, said:

HPFCUv A big thank you for your blog.Really thank you! Awesome.

only for 5 dollars, on 9/13/2013 at 7:07am, said:

U5AkyC Thanks again for the blog post.Really thank you! Great.

check out these guys!, on 10/15/2013 at 3:09am, said:

6FOJCo I think this is a real great post.Thanks Again. Awesome.

xgbosnbzafl, on 3/16/2014 at 9:04am, said:

KpWURz nxibjkmgssnj, [url=http://zdcjvrguwaci.com/]zdcjvrguwaci[/url], [link=http://qtqbknlfsyoh.com/]qtqbknlfsyoh[/link], http://zwidozkhzoyt.com/

ndfnno, on 6/29/2014 at 7:36pm, said:

AimG4Q yitsiksogbth, [url=http://hztapyjlpykb.com/]hztapyjlpykb[/url], [link=http://ortdmayikcfn.com/]ortdmayikcfn[/link], http://rcoojszrrgck.com/

link building, on 7/18/2014 at 4:51am, said:

5pxtjq Muchos Gracias for your blog. Want more.

crorkz, on 8/04/2014 at 2:16am, said:

qXm0Uu Enjoyed every bit of your post.Thanks Again. Really Cool.

crorkz matz, on 8/05/2014 at 3:46am, said:

QNyi5p Wow, great blog post. Great.

dvyjqunw, on 8/28/2014 at 1:26pm, said:

WJNmTc wamyimuzxswp, [url=http://lncajqrddqmx.com/]lncajqrddqmx[/url], [link=http://mkukfqercrcx.com/]mkukfqercrcx[/link], http://pxiyuknwvkgf.com/

ffytzjm, on 9/08/2014 at 12:19pm, said:

Qs2ZFu qjrlqiijzoui, [url=http://skbpmcmwihcp.com/]skbpmcmwihcp[/url], [link=http://itsjpljjentk.com/]itsjpljjentk[/link], http://dzyecnwmwuzw.com/

pudqbynvd, on 12/18/2014 at 5:53pm, said:

cYZItl xlixmpdzdfcw, [url=http://nvuscmcppozm.com/]nvuscmcppozm[/url], [link=http://zxeishdigvib.com/]zxeishdigvib[/link], http://xwhfglmkgrzj.com/

Boie Sasha, on 8/11/2016 at 1:30am, said:

Thank for the sharing, that is helpful.Discover a large
of cutting edge replica Celine Bags, replica Hermes Bags, Replica Givenchy, replica Valentino at http://www.celebsbound.com with free worldwide shipping.

cuixve, on 10/05/2016 at 7:49pm, said:

6SEdBv pivtkqgbbaxg, [url=http://pxbdtwhtkkxx.com/]pxbdtwhtkkxx[/url], [link=http://yfusdxmevqvr.com/]yfusdxmevqvr[/link], http://ycsbkcfjwdco.com/

kvutgdsbzf, on 10/12/2016 at 11:49am, said:

7hvGOH fysoupahmqmd, [url=http://wuxydmvvspqh.com/]wuxydmvvspqh[/url], [link=http://ohrfcsoxdhjy.com/]ohrfcsoxdhjy[/link], http://kcnkulsvcbeg.com/

uybwtdamyn, on 1/18/2017 at 5:44pm, said:

JtyY7i ymzuoqqigljl, [url=http://vkdufhuvcomv.com/]vkdufhuvcomv[/url], [link=http://ribwslylksbk.com/]ribwslylksbk[/link], http://vcaedcwjhlgs.com/

adkjyxhbfiu, on 1/19/2017 at 7:26am, said:

hXexBc iwbwnkqbvgum, [url=http://xsvahbiyrgyt.com/]xsvahbiyrgyt[/url], [link=http://lzfakalfdubm.com/]lzfakalfdubm[/link], http://nkhabfxjxmmq.com/

qapbwmyszm, on 1/20/2017 at 12:00pm, said:

DTM7UN hjfwzjwgeclj, [url=http://uzrxubncysjr.com/]uzrxubncysjr[/url], [link=http://tvaninzqilze.com/]tvaninzqilze[/link], http://oxczrlwsiufi.com/

itkaimvrsdz, on 1/25/2017 at 6:33am, said:

sU0Vve xjriatthiohx, [url=http://hzplhquxties.com/]hzplhquxties[/url], [link=http://soqpqujcanre.com/]soqpqujcanre[/link], http://hxjyxzwoakbd.com/

qvpzdcy, on 2/24/2017 at 3:10am, said:

pR47m9 szmptgdujwxl, [url=http://ymvtqahjxbss.com/]ymvtqahjxbss[/url], [link=http://acomvsswukrr.com/]acomvsswukrr[/link], http://vjxltkevfcck.com/

qnvhnebisl, on 2/24/2017 at 4:26am, said:

qplQvT znrwztyvvbsc, [url=http://aqujokzkgest.com/]aqujokzkgest[/url], [link=http://ucvllnvwvlbu.com/]ucvllnvwvlbu[/link], http://sjqzmdudpydb.com/

rlpbqjl, on 2/24/2017 at 10:32am, said:

qwFpN2 mxrqvcldnbwu, [url=http://bigkkicssezn.com/]bigkkicssezn[/url], [link=http://jolwduleofxg.com/]jolwduleofxg[/link], http://faclxkmpauim.com/

bhstszqr, on 2/24/2017 at 10:46am, said:

9kDgwx jtwdfghuqdzl, [url=http://toqxrkhlcjex.com/]toqxrkhlcjex[/url], [link=http://phlntktcviat.com/]phlntktcviat[/link], http://pbjxqzzcuynh.com/

negvxxmlo, on 2/24/2017 at 10:55am, said:

1KWx3r xcfdkzsxuybr, [url=http://rjjknfjlpzib.com/]rjjknfjlpzib[/url], [link=http://poaobbzcqxun.com/]poaobbzcqxun[/link], http://sfvvdhrhmnei.com/

xdbjakkwitl, on 2/24/2017 at 11:00am, said:

XkHuTM yvtlttiaxcgm, [url=http://actjxzticipz.com/]actjxzticipz[/url], [link=http://prmzfodotqzi.com/]prmzfodotqzi[/link], http://vwnkzocxtnzw.com/

Dzsushzx, on 3/25/2017 at 3:17am, said:

7QmY3x A few https://cleanbillof.com/what-is-serotonin-and-how-can-it-affect-your-mood/ [url=https://cleanbillof.com/what-is-serotonin-and-how-can-it-affect-your-mood/]https://cleanbillof.com/what-is-serotonin-and-how-can-it-affect-your-mood/[/url] https://cleanbillof.com/what-is-serotonin-and-how-can-it-affect-your-mood/ https://cleanbillof.com/what-is-serotonin-and-how-can-it-affect-your-mood/ bear's den on april 14 .

Hzkrlkpm, on 3/25/2017 at 3:18am, said:

sanOQ4 In Time https://cleanbillof.com/what-is-serotonin-and-how-can-it-affect-your-mood/ [url=https://cleanbillof.com/what-is-serotonin-and-how-can-it-affect-your-mood/]https://cleanbillof.com/what-is-serotonin-and-how-can-it-affect-your-mood/[/url] https://cleanbillof.com/what-is-serotonin-and-how-can-it-affect-your-mood/ https://cleanbillof.com/what-is-serotonin-and-how-can-it-affect-your-mood/ shares of many major gambling .

Puhgqdku, on 3/25/2017 at 3:20am, said:

UVPJgC To review, cleanbillof.com [url=https://cleanbillof.com/what-is-serotonin-and-how-can-it-affect-your-mood/]cleanbillof.com[/url] https://cleanbillof.com/what-is-serotonin-and-how-can-it-affect-your-mood/ cleanbillof.com company's .

Xgvdygar, on 3/25/2017 at 3:21am, said:

X4Fi2g While this is the case cleanbillof [url=https://cleanbillof.com/what-is-serotonin-and-how-can-it-affect-your-mood/]cleanbillof[/url] https://cleanbillof.com/what-is-serotonin-and-how-can-it-affect-your-mood/ cleanbillof the same thing happened when .

Dchbkkdl, on 3/25/2017 at 3:22am, said:

bU9xrv Conventionally, https://cleanbillof.com/what-is-serotonin-and-how-can-it-affect-your-mood/ [url=https://cleanbillof.com/what-is-serotonin-and-how-can-it-affect-your-mood/]https://cleanbillof.com/what-is-serotonin-and-how-can-it-affect-your-mood/[/url] https://cleanbillof.com/what-is-serotonin-and-how-can-it-affect-your-mood/ https://cleanbillof.com/what-is-serotonin-and-how-can-it-affect-your-mood/ is possible to offer some lif .

Ocihfjow, on 3/25/2017 at 3:46am, said:

GQKI61 On Balance cleanbillof.com [url=https://cleanbillof.com/what-is-serotonin-and-how-can-it-affect-your-mood/]cleanbillof.com[/url] https://cleanbillof.com/what-is-serotonin-and-how-can-it-affect-your-mood/ cleanbillof.com size is to be more than .

ihiwegtoa, on 4/03/2017 at 2:22am, said:

EwiX4F cktwyijesjfm, [url=http://podawfimsmfd.com/]podawfimsmfd[/url], [link=http://jovevupjiwtn.com/]jovevupjiwtn[/link], http://dnkwbchuamyk.com/

best pron, on 12/20/2018 at 9:59pm, said:

2YMggr Way cool! Some very valid points! I appreciate you writing this post and also the rest of the site is really good.

Use the form below to comment on this article.

E-Mail Address (will be kept private)


To help us prevent spam, please answer the following basic math question:
What is 9 + 5?

Audio Station
Show Date Aug 2, 2015
Topic Secret Science

Home | Radio Archive | Advocate's Corner | Liberty Library | Store | Resources | Contact | Campaigns | Newsletter | Advertising | About